Sunday, December 11, 2011

Inspired #6 - Jerry Sandusky Abuse Scandal




The past month will perhaps have been the strangest month I ever live. When I woke up on November 4 2011, I did not expect the future of Penn State to change radically in front of my eyes. Since it was our bye week, I was planning to watch the other teams across the college football landscape. Instead, the news came out that former Penn State Defensive Coordinator Jerry Sandusky was now facing over 40+ charges of sex crimes with young boys.  Along two with Sandusky, two prominent members of the Penn State faced charges of perjury based on testimony made during the grand jury. After reading the grand jury, I felt physically ill as I read of the stories of abuse these boys allegedly faced from Sandusky. Reading that report, I knew that things would never be the same in Happy Valley.

 The story quickly spread like wildfire across the various news sites and social media services across the world. Just hours, after the story broke in the United States, I knew people in Australia asking what is going on at Penn State. The lead story of NBC nightly news that evening was the Jerry Sandusky abuse scandal. In the week that followed, I saw at least 10 to 15 news vans parked outside of Beaver Stadium each morning. ESPN effectively covered the scandal 24/7 during that immediate week following the release of the charges.

On Wednesday November 8, 2011, the Pennsylvania State Board of Trustees decided to fire Joe Paterno and Graham Spanier for their actions in the cover up. Within minutes of the Board of Trustees announcement thousands of students flocked to Beaver Canyon. For the first few hours, the gathered students remained peaceful and somber. Around midnight, the situation took a turn for the worse as the behavior shifted from peaceful to violent. Students overturned a news van and pulled out light posts along Beaver Canyon. Eventually, the police were able to gain control of the situation and dispersed the crowd.

As a student at Penn State, I have had difficulty understanding the actions taken by all of those involved in the cover up. I am waiting to withhold complete judgment until all of the facts come out during the trial, the facts as known are damning for all of those involved. How can Coach Paterno who has made a career requiring football players to do more than the minimum, just do the minimum when told of these serious allegations? How did Penn State benefit from covering up these serious allegations? Why did it take so long for Penn State, outside of Graham Spanier, to respond following the indictments?

For better or worse, this scandal has revealed the power of the media to shape the scandal in this new digital age. Since the scandal, I have read many "facts" being reported by the media on various social media sites. Some of these so-called facts went so far beyond the truth of the situation that I became angered at the lack of journalistic integrity. I am sorry, but starting a rumor that the Second Mile is prostituting young boys to rich donors is despicable. The fact that multiple news sites picked up this story without a repeatable source displays the slow decay of journalistic integrity within the industry.
The actions of the leaders at Penn State in the immediate aftermath of the scandal will become a case study in what not to do in the digital age. The only statement to come out of Penn State in the initial aftermath was the misguided statement from then President Graham Spanier. Perhaps if Penn State had reacted in the immediate aftermath, they could have changed the story told by the media. Instead, the media had free-reign to report the story in ways that sold newspapers and got television viewers. By the time Penn State reacted, it was too late to change the presentment of the story told by the national media. In the digital age, organizations and people must react quickly to stay on top of how the media presents the story. 

This scandal will hang over Penn State for the years to come until the trial and subsequent lawsuits are settled. Unfortunately, those not involved in the scandal will end up paying the most, as the scandal continues to loom overhead. The actions of a few do not define the masses. Going into the future my only hope is that the alleged victims of sexual abuse will obtain a sense of closure should Jerry Sandusky be found guilty of these alleged despicable crimes.

Inspired #5 - Wikileaks


      On October 25 2011, we had the opportunity to listen to Philip J. Crowley speak at the Lewis Katz Building regarding Wikileaks. PJ Crowley famously stated that handling of Bradley Manning was, "ridiculous and counterproductive and stupid." Bradley Manning is the soldier accused of providing Wikileaks with the classified government intelligence. Three days after the comment, Crowley resigned from his position as State Department spokesperson. It was definitely very interesting listening to the opinion's of PJ Crowley. He brought a unique perspective on Wikileaks that not many people have.

The issue with Wikileaks release was not the actual information contained within the cable release. While there was a few embarrassing releases, most of the information contained within the leak was day to diplomatic operations. Instead, the damage done by Wikileaks come from the release of sources and methods American diplomats use to gather information. Taking IST 402: Introduction to the Intelligence Community this semester with Professor Don Shemanski, he has stressed that losing the sources and methods was the real damage caused by the Wikileaks release. Now anyone in the world can find out the kinds of the information that American diplomats are looking for in the release of the diplomatic cables.
Wikileaks has created an interesting debate online on whether the organization deserves journalistic privileges. Supporters of Wikileaks argue that the organization is fulfilling a journalistic role by publishing information provided by whistleblowers. Opponents of the organization consider the actions of the organization as criminal in nature. Recently, the organization won the top Australian Journalist prize, the Walkey Award. Winning such, a prestigious award does help solidify Wikileaks as a journalistic organization.

Personally, I find myself split between the two vastly different opinions of the organization. One the one hand, Wikileaks does not gather any of this information themselves. Instead, "whistleblowers" provide all of the information provided to Wikileaks. If you start censoring an organization because of the information it provides, you create a slippery-slop going into the future. If we start censoring Wikileaks now, what is to stop similar censorship in the future? Meanwhile, I cannot justify the actions by Wikileaks in releasing the classified information without censoring certain details. While Wikileaks claims that, they acted the Federal Government to redact important information before the release, which was nothing more than a publicity act. The Federal Government would never willingly certain parts of classified information so an organization could release the rest. By just the releasing information in mass, Wikileaks compromised vital sources all around the world. Future sources will now be hesitant to work with foreign governments because there is a chance that Wikileaks later releases that information.

One of the more interesting things regarding the whole Wikileaks situation is the rise of hacktivism in support of the organization. When MasterCard, Visa and PayPal shut off donations to the site, Hacktivists responded by shutting down their site for hours. Had those organizations not tried to shut down Wikileaks effectively, it is possible that rise of hacktivism earlier this year may have never happened. Instead, we saw Anonymous rise to further prominence and the rise and fall of Lulz Sec.

Saturday, December 10, 2011

Inspired #3 - Reddit




In recent years, social news websites have grown in popularity. A few popular social news sites include Slashdot, Digg, and Reddit. Reddit differentiates itself from these other social news sites by allowing users to vote stories up or down and allowing them to create Subreddits. Unlike other popular news sites, users exclusively determine which stories make it to the "front page." Popular stories will get up votes while users downvote unpopular stories. Reddit also allows users to create subreddits, or a smaller community about a specific topic. For example, a subreddit exists to cover only Penn State topics. This creates an interesting dynamic where subreddits become Internet communities. Reddit is one technology that Friedman would absolutely love. Reddit is creating a space for people to communicate globally, no matter where a person is from.

One of the fascinating things about Reddit is the sense of community within the various subreddits and the community as a large. Within the community at large, there is a sense of belonging of a bigger entity. People are not simply users, but fellow redditors. Redditors have a history of coming to the aid of fellow redditors in need. In 2011, created the site randomactsofpizza subreddit to help fellow redditors in need. The idea behind the site was to connect the less fortunate to those that are willing to help. To request or offer pizza, one simply has to post within the subreddit. If someone feels particularly moved by your request, that person can then place an order for that request. One of the interesting dynamic of the movement is that the two co-founders have never actually met.  The two connected online and have since started a movement to help the less fortunate online without ever meeting the other person in person.

On Reddit, two interesting dynamics exist that would both impress and annoy Evgeny Morozov. Historically, Reddit has become well known for its user's generosity. Last year, redditors donated over $600,000 to DonorsChoose in support of Stephen Colbert's March to Keep Fear Alive campaign. Redditors also donated over $150,000 to support Haiti after the 2010 earthquake. Instead of using technology to promote slacktivism, users created a community of activism and charity. However, there does exist within Reddit a community that are simple slacktivists. A recent trend on Reddit is that a user will agree to donate X for every upvote the post receives. The slacktivists simply upvote the post and do nothing else. These are the actions that Morozov so reviled in The Net Delusion.
Reddit is not without criticism however. 

While the website does allow users to connect from all around the world, it does allow "shady" users to connect. On Reddit, there is very little moderation and users can post pretty much anything but illegal content. Until recently, there existed a semi-large subreddit dedicated to the posting of questionable pictures of underage females, or jailbait." While the main jailbait subreddit was eventually shut down, various smaller subreddits still exist today.  While technically legal, this creates an ethical dilemma for moderators. Where do you draw the line and begin censoring questionable material? While the line eventually became quite clear for moderators, the heart of the issue remains a problem for the internet as a whole.

Inspired #4 - Steve Jobs




On October 5, Steve Jobs passed away due to the relapse of his pancreatic cancer. Steve Jobs is perhaps the most inspirational and controversial leader the tech industry has ever seen. Everything that Steve Jobs touched turned to gold and became widely successful. He was not without critics however, who argued that he never truly invented anything. Instead, he simply tweaked other people's idea to fit his vision. Despite what your opinion of Steve Jobs is, the tech industry lost a giant they can never replace.

I find myself more on the side that Steve Jobs did not invent anything and simply tweaked other people's ideas. While he may not have ever invented something, he was the best at what he did. Steve Jobs could see the flaws in other people's designs, and he would not rest until he recreated that product in his perfect vision. He changed the entire MP3 player market, because he thought that every product on the market "truly sucked." Therefore, Steve Jobs went to work at perfecting the MP3 player and introduced the world to the iPod in 2001. The iPod completely revolutionized the market and remains the number one MP3 player in the United States today. When Steve Jobs saw the cell phone and tablet markets, he went through the exact same process as he did with the MP3. Today, it is almost impossible to find a phone that does not have at least he most basic "Smartphone" technologies. By introducing the iPad, Jobs once again revolutionized a market once thought dead. Owning a tablet computer suddenly became the newest thing that you needed to have. Before the iPad tablets, were clunky and required a stylus to operate. Now, tablets no longer require a stylus and instead operate using the multi-touch systems.

While I do not want to speak ill of the dead, I have unfortunately lost some respect for Steve Jobs after the release of his official biography. In his biography, it is quite apparent that Steve Jobs does not appreciate anybody tweaking "his" ideas.  In his biography Steve Jobs said, 

Our lawsuit is saying, “Google, you fucking ripped off the iPhone, wholesale ripped us off.” Grand theft. I will spend my last dying breath if I need to, and I will spend every penny of Apple’s $40 billion in the bank, to right this wrong. I’m going to destroy Android, because it’s a stolen product. I’m willing to go to thermonuclear war on this. They are scared to death, because they know they are guilty. Outside of Search, Google’s products—Android, Google Docs—are shit.
Personally, I find Steve Jobs views to be entirely hypocritical. He made his entire career based on tweaking other people's ideas. Throughout his career, Jobs took other people's idea and made them fit his vision. However, when somebody does the exact same thing to him he is furious. How can he base his entire career off other people's ideas and then are made when somebody else "copies" him?  Perhaps Bill Gates said it best when he said, "I think there’s more than one way of looking at it. I think it’s more like we both had this rich neighbor named Xerox and I broke into his house to steal the TV set and found out that you had already stolen it.”

http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2011/11/14/111114fa_fact_gladwell

Inspired #2 - Anonymous



Last year around this time, Anonymous became a household name across America. In response to the treatment of Bradley Manning and Wikileaks, Anonymous launched a series of attacks across the internet. Anonymous Targets of Anonymous included Amazon, MasterCard, PayPal, Visa and Sony. Through a coordinated distributed denial of service attack, Anonymous brought successfully brought down the websites of MasterCard, PayPal and Visa. 

The attacks by Anonymous were not the first attacks from the hacker organization. In 2008, Anonymous targeted the Church of Scientology after the church tried to take down a video of a Tom Cruise interview. Called Project Chanology, Anonymous began a series of attacks against the church. A few methods of attacks included: distributed denial of service attack, black faxes, prank calls, and pizza deliveries. Eventually, the group planned a series of protests against the Church at various locations around the world. As part of the protest, the protestors wore Guy Fawkes masks from V for Vendetta. The Guy Fawkes Mask would become the symbol of anonymous. 

The rise of groups like Anonymous certainly raises interesting ethical questions for the public. The actions of Anonymous are not simply hacking in the traditional sense. Instead, these groups are participating in the rise of hacktivism. Hacktivism is the use of computers and computer networks as a means to promote political ends. Just last year, the public became more aware of hacktivism as Anonymous and Lulz Sec both participated in Operation #AntiSec following the Wikileaks backlash.
Anonymous and the rise of hacktivism raises serious ethical concerns that we as a society will need to address in the near future. As a society will we treat hacktivism as another form of activism or will we consider it cyber terrorism? There is no easy answer as both sides of the argument have valid arguments and concerns. If you consider hacktivism a valid form of activism, where do you draw the line between activism and hacking? If someone were to hack Bank of America and stole money protesting the mortgage crisis, would that be considered hacktivism or hacking? The line between hacking and hacktivism is razor thin, and groups like anonymous walk that line every time they operate. The sooner we develop a standard as a society, the better off we will be.

Personally, I find myself constantly in an internal debate between whether Anonymous is a benefit or negative portion of society. As an organization, Anonymous has done both good and bad for the society as a whole. One day they may be shutting down Visa and MasterCard; the next they are shutting down a child pornography network. The "anonymous" nature of the organization certainly does not make it easier for me to make my mind up on the nature of the organization. Anybody on the Internet could claim that Anonymous s did something, because no one really knows whom Anonymous is. Good or bad the actions of Anonymous have done one thing spectacularly well. Anonymous and Lulz Sec have pointed out the pathetic nature of our cyber-security initiatives to the non-technological public. People tend to panic when "hackers" hacked the Central Intelligence Agency. While the CIA hack was a joke, it will at least generate a public discussion on cyber security initiatives in the United States.